Hearts & Minds - Information for ChangeSM

Racial Profiling

Americans depend on the police force to keep them safe. Policemen put their lives on the line to protect us. However, they sometimes cause injustice and inequality.  

Racial profiling—the intended targeting by the police of a specific race or ethnicity—can take many forms, from stopping a disproportionate number of minorities on the freeway to randomly searching minorities on the streets. When it occurs, an unfair number of minorities are unjustifiably stopped, and a disproportionate number are convicted of crimes such as those dealing with drugs. In reality, many white people are committing the same crimes, but are less likely to be stopped and convicted.

CCRBs
Some state and local governments have created Civilian Complaint Review Boards (CCRBs). These review police actions and investigate citizen complaints. Many now require police to document data such as the race and gender of people whom they stop. This helps to show when police target certain groups.  

These are positive actions, but they have not been taken far enough. For instance, while the CCRBs in New York City received 25,800 complaints between 1993 and 1998, only 8,700 were fully investigated. In the end, only 1.5% of all complaints ended in disciplinary action.* New York, like other cities, also limits citizen participation in reviewing police actions. Citizens can only passively view investigations conducted by the police’s own internal affairs bureaus.
* (Source: Fact Sheet, Columbia University Coalition for Police Reform).

More must be done to ensure the effectiveness of CCRBs and to allow citizens to review data that is not controlled by the police. Every case with serious evidence of misconduct should be thoroughly evaluated. If substantiated, punitive action against officers should be consistently enforced.

Prospects for Reform
There is a rising tide of public protest against this problem. For example, “Redeem the Dream” took place in Washington, D.C. in summer 2000. This demonstration attracted thousands of people and the media. Well-known speakers, such as Martin Luther King III and Rev. Al Sharpton spoke against racial profiling.  

Police reform can encourage civilians to trust the police to protect them, and, in turn, to assist the police in protecting others. As long as the public is frightened of the police, crime enforcement will be difficult - fewer people will understand that it is in their best interest to work with the police to help their own communities.  

Communities composed of minorities, which are disproportionately affected by police misconduct, are especially prone to distrust the police. Police refusal to publicly admit their flaws also encourages citizens’ skepticism. To gain communities’ trust, police must be held fully accountable for all of their actions and consistently act as positive role models in these communities.

Many reforms may be necessary in order to restore citizens’ trust in the police. Hopefully, after more discourse within the community and help from the government, racial profiling will no longer be an issue.

By Katherine Bromberg, Hearts and Minds Volunteer

Free Newsletter

More Articles on Social Issues
Top of Page  |  Home Page  |  Site Guide
Contact Us

This web page and entire website © Copyright: 1997 - 2007 by
Hearts and Minds Network, Inc.
http://www.heartsandminds.org/police/profiling.htm - latest text changes April 7, 2006.

Helpful Info
Volunteering

Self-Help

Inspiring Quotes

Site Guide

Hearts & Minds
Volunteer with Us

Donate/Become a Member

About Us

Copyrights, Reprints & Important Notes

Home Page